Join CoDA

  • Meeting summary

    Quick recap

    The meeting focused on two main legislative initiatives: healthcare reform and home care worker protections. Assemblymember Keith Powers provided updates on the New York Health Act and home care worker legislation, explaining that while the healthcare bill faces significant challenges due to entrenched interests, the home care bill aims to end 24-hour shifts and improve worker standards. The group also discussed the status of the budget negotiations in Albany, which are delayed due to disagreements on immigration policy, climate bill reforms, and auto insurance. Additionally, the meeting covered upcoming community events, including a trivia night planned for April 29th at ABC Beer Co., and addressed concerns about the recent closure of the Bellevue shelter system, with discussions about forming a Community Advisory Board to address community impacts.

    Next steps

    Summary

    Merchant House Preservation Discussion

    The group discussed the preservation of the Merchant House at 29 East 4th Street, a landmark building with a secret underground passage. CODA_LES explained that while the Merchant House Society opposes any construction on the adjacent vacant lot, they are seeking a letter of support for archaeological digging instead of heavy construction, as this would allow for the discovery of artifacts related to slavery and African American history. The discussion included details about the nearby Manuel Plaza, named after early freed African Americans who received land in the 1800s, and confirmed that the Merchant House is located between 3rd and Lafayette streets. The conversation ended with an agreement to draft and distribute a letter of support via email blast to all relevant parties.

    Key Legislation Updates Discussion

    Keith discussed two key pieces of legislation during the meeting. He announced the successful passage of a bill regarding in-state tuition deadlines for SUNY students, which will allow them to file late and still qualify for in-state tuition rates. Regarding the Healthcare for All Act, Keith expressed support for universal healthcare but noted that the bill has been held up in the legislature due to entrenched interests and lack of gubernatorial support, making passage unlikely this year. He also discussed a bill regarding reforming 24-hour shift practices for home care workers, which aims to cap work hours and improve worker standards, though implementation would require additional funding and system reforms.

    Healthcare Legislation Status Update

    Keith discussed the status of healthcare legislation, including efforts to prevent people from losing healthcare coverage and funding for Medicaid and essential plans. He explained that the current budget negotiations are delayed due to several issues, including disagreements over immigration policy, auto insurance reform, climate bill changes, and aid to New York City. Keith noted that while the April 1st deadline has passed, negotiations are expected to resume after the holidays. The meeting also touched on a new bill passed for college students and concerns about low wages for home care workers.

    Worker Rights Bill Support Discussion

    The meeting focused on discussing support for three bills related to worker rights, including two state bills and one city bill regarding home health workers. The group agreed to support all three bills, with particular attention to a bill affecting Chinatown workers where abuse had previously occurred. The board decided to implement a new Action Network platform to help members easily contact elected officials in support of these initiatives, with plans to send out background information and links for members to take action.

    Home Healthcare Bill Discussion

    The group discussed concerns about Chris Marte’s bill regarding home healthcare workers, particularly focusing on opposition from unions like DC37 and 1199. The main issue raised was that the bill could lead to decreased wages for workers due to Medicaid reimbursement limitations when hours are reduced. The group decided to support state-level bills instead of the city bill and agreed to review the specific language of the legislation, with Ted offering to forward a relevant New York Times article for review.

    Healthcare Legislation and Policy Updates

    The discussion focused on healthcare legislation and policy updates. The speaker discussed their co-sponsorship of the New York State Home Care Aid Hours legislation, which is currently in the labor committee but may not pass this session due to budget negotiations and fiscal complexity. They also addressed the New York Health Act, emphasizing the need for universal healthcare in the state, and highlighted an urgent issue regarding 450,000 New Yorkers who will lose healthcare coverage on July 1st through the essential plan. The speaker mentioned a bill being introduced to provide temporary coverage through January, with hopes that Democratic control of the House would provide better negotiating leverage for a longer-term solution.

    Legislative Initiatives and Policy Updates

    The discussion focused on several legislative initiatives, including a bill to allow purchasing medications from Canada, which the speaker indicated they would investigate further. The conversation also covered ongoing budget negotiations being held up by discussions around auto insurance reforms and climate standards, with the speaker emphasizing the importance of maintaining renewable energy standards. Additionally, the speaker outlined efforts to advance immigration-related bills, including the MELT Act and the ICE Contract Transparency Act, which would address ICE operations and private company contracts with immigration authorities.

    Trivia Night Event Planning

    The group discussed organizing a trivia night event on the 29th at ABC Beer Co., with Jenna handling the flyer creation. They addressed concerns about potential competition with the Taste of the Lower East Side event happening on the same day, though they determined the events would not conflict. The group agreed to form a committee including Darrell and Debbie to develop questions, with plans to potentially offer refreshments and a small prize for winners, and Marquise offered to contribute $100 toward drinks.

    Upcoming Events and Petition Updates

    The team discussed upcoming events, including a flyer distribution planned for early next week and an Earth Day event on April 22nd involving corporate volunteers working in community gardens. They reviewed petition performance, noting poor turnout which CODA_LES attributed to endorsing candidates whose supporters didn’t actively collect signatures. The discussion concluded with updates on petition challenges, including one against Lila’s candidacy, and a reminder that future petition efforts should be better coordinated, particularly for next year’s district leader elections.

    County Committee Meeting Planning

    The meeting focused on scheduling and planning for upcoming events and elections. The main discussion centered around a county committee meeting on April 20th at 6 PM to appoint a new district leader following Jasmine Sanchez’s resignation to pursue an Assembly seat. The group discussed phone banking efforts to reach 50 people on their contact list, with a goal of getting at least 20 responses. They also planned an event for April 29th that would include trivia, food, and snacks, with plans to have the new district leader emcee the event. The conversation ended with discussions about poll worker recruitment for upcoming elections and planning for future community events, including a festival and potential volunteer opportunities.

    Bellevue Shelter System Changes

    The meeting focused on changes to the Bellevue shelter system, where Project Renewal moved everyone out and plans to reintroduce services, including an intake center with 117 beds for overnight stays and a family unit for adult family members. The group discussed forming a Community Advisory Board (CAB) to address concerns and provide feedback on the changes, with Susan taking the lead on resurrecting an existing but inactive CAB. Participants expressed concerns about the administration’s communication and implementation of the changes, emphasizing the need for better coordination with local law enforcement and community stakeholders.

  • Subject: CODA Board Meeting Minutes — February 2, 2026 (7:00–8:45 PM)

    Hi all,

    Attached below are the consolidated minutes from the CODA Board meeting held on February 2, 2026, which began at 7:00 PM and adjourned at 8:45 PM.

    Attendees: Ayo; Marquis; Anthony; Esther; Albert; Jake (attended and took notes)
    Note: Jenna attended the early portion of the meeting and exited for the board-only section.

    —

    # CODA Board Meeting Minutes — February 2, 2026 (7:00–8:45 PM)

    ## 1. Call to Order and Purpose
    Ayo called the meeting to order at 7:00 PM. This was an unscheduled meeting convened to address urgent items, primarily:
    – Final planning for the upcoming fundraiser/gala
    – CODA organizational status and near-term strategy (board-only portion)

    ## 2. Housekeeping: Minutes, Records, and Accuracy
    – Ayo stated that meeting minutes must be kept in one centralized location.
    – Ayo is collecting prior minutes from Katie and others, including minutes Jake has circulated.
    – Ayo noted that prior AI-generated summaries require review and correction for nuance and accuracy.
    – Jake is to continue taking notes, with the understanding that minutes will be reviewed before finalization/distribution.

    ## 3. Fundraising Update: ActBlue, Dues, and Current Totals
    ### ActBlue Setup and Membership Dues
    – ActBlue is now active and functioning well.
    – 22 members have paid dues via ActBlue, totaling $575.
    – The membership will be notified again to pay dues promptly.
    – Members must be paid up to vote on endorsements, consistent with the bylaws and eligibility requirements.

    ### Gala/Fundraiser Ticket Sales and Donations
    – 12 tickets/donations have been received to date for the gala, totaling $1,076.
    – Ayo reported that some contributions qualify as sponsorships based on amount.
    – Ayo noted that current gala totals do not yet include local elected officials; Ayo expects additional contributions.

    ### Outreach Activity
    – Ayo sent 10–15 sponsorship requests to a wide range of candidates, including:
    – Congressional races (NY-10, NY-12)
    – Statewide races (e.g., Comptroller, Governor)
    – Anthony requested a list of outreach targets so follow-up efforts can be coordinated and not duplicated.
    – Ayo agreed to send a follow-up list and assign targets for outreach.

    ## 4. Fundraiser Logistics and Day-Of Planning
    ### Staffing and Arrival Time
    – Event time confirmed as 1:00–4:00 PM.
    – Ayo stated a setup team is needed by 12:00 PM.
    – Esther confirmed she can be there by 12:00 PM.
    – Anthony confirmed he can be there by 12:00 PM.
    – Additional arrivals at 12:00 PM were confirmed by at least one more attendee.

    ### Door/Check-In and Payments
    – The group confirmed a check-in process:
    – Printed list of paid members/attendees
    – QR code available at the door for payments
    – Esther agreed to manage the door/check-in from 12:00–2:00 PM, with flexibility to continue as needed.
    – A request was made to print a list of who has paid (dues/tickets) for smooth check-in.

    ### Program Timing
    – Discussion concluded the formal program should start around the midpoint of the event.
    – Target start time for the formal portion of the program: approximately 2:00 PM (with flexibility if needed).

    ### Badges / Name Tags
    – Plan: guests fill out their own badges on arrival.
    – Optional: add a small CODA logo on badge inserts if time allows.

    ### Website Updates (Urgent)
    – It was confirmed that the ActBlue dues link and fundraiser information were not prominently posted on the CODA website.
    – Ayo noted discomfort sharing the website on sponsorship letters given outdated/insufficient content.
    – Marquis volunteered to update the website, including posting the flyer/QR code and ActBlue links prominently (homepage priority), to be done as soon as possible.

    ## 5. Honorary Recognition, Certificates, and Photos
    ### Honorary List
    – Ayo described an honorary list of approximately 20 names, including founders/early supporters.
    – Some individuals are deceased or difficult to contact; outreach will focus first on those with known contact information.

    ### Outreach Letter and Photo Request
    – Ayo has a letter ready to send to honorees requesting:
    – Support/attendance where possible
    – Submission of historic photos, especially from the 1990s and early CODA years
    – Ayo will send the letter to at least 10 contacts immediately and will coordinate with Donna/Ted for additional contacts.

    ### Certificates and Framing
    – Plan: framed 8.5″ x 11″ certificates recognizing founding/early contributions.
    – Ayo will order additional frames.
    – Jenna volunteered to help with certificate design (language + layout), though printing support is limited.
    – Event-day recognition will also include scrolling names/slides displayed on the venue monitor.

    ## 6. Communications to Membership: Notices to Send
    The following reminders/notices were confirmed:
    1. Dues reminder (required for endorsement voting eligibility)
    2. Fundraiser reminder (entry and/or payment guidance)
    3. Endorsement dates reminder
    – Zoom endorsement meeting: February 10 at 6:30 PM
    – In-person endorsement meeting: February 11 at 6:30 PM, at the usual 5th Street location

    It was discussed that at least two rounds of reminders should be sent.

    ## 7. Restaurant Gratitude / Tip and Financial Recording
    – The restaurant is providing the space and food at no charge; the group agreed CODA should tip staff to maintain a strong relationship.
    – Past tips were discussed (approx. $150–$300).
    – The amount will be decided toward the end of the event based on overall funds raised.
    – It was noted that all expenditures (including tips) must be properly recorded and compliant with applicable finance rules.

    ## 8. Board-Only Discussion: CODA Status, Representation, and Strategy
    (Jenna exited for this portion.)

    ### Context: CODA Standing and Recent Losses
    – Ayo provided context that CODA has lost some political standing in recent years, including:
    – Loss of the female district leader seat after an extended vacancy
    – Potential loss of CODA’s state committee representation

    ### Role Clarification
    – Brief overview provided of district leader responsibilities (election operations, poll staffing/coordinators, committee functions, broader organizing).
    – State committee role summarized (attendance at periodic meetings and participation in party governance/rules).

    ### State Committee Situation
    – Ayo reported that Michael Corbett (Eleanor Roosevelt Club) is running for state committee against Anthony.
    – Anthony stated he is not running for re-election due to capacity constraints and intends to refocus his work toward strengthening CODA.
    – Discussion emphasized CODA may lose this position and should plan accordingly.

    ### Strategic Direction and Priorities
    Consensus themes included:
    – Prioritize strengthening CODA membership and leadership pipeline.
    – Protect Marquis’s district leader seat and plan to build toward winning back the female district leader seat.
    – Avoid fighting on multiple fronts; focus on rebuilding strength and presence.
    – Emphasize forward-looking organizing rather than protracted internal conflict.

    ## 9. Meeting Culture, Structure, and Member Retention
    – Concerns raised that prolonged back-and-forth discussion can deter new members.
    – Suggestions included:
    – A designated timekeeper
    – Clear agenda discipline
    – Limiting “business” to ~45 minutes, followed by social/community-building time
    – Emphasis that respectful discussion is required and yelling/disrespectful conduct is unacceptable.

    ## 10. Governance: Elections and Bylaws
    ### Election Timing
    – Broad agreement emerged that CODA needs elections promptly to stabilize leadership and distribute responsibilities.
    – It was clarified that bylaws revisions do not need to be completed before holding elections.

    ### Bylaws Reference
    – The bylaws language was reviewed; nominations are to be made at a meeting prior to the election meeting.
    – The group discussed that while this often implies ~30 days (monthly meeting cycle), it does not strictly require a 30-day delay if special meetings are held.

    ### Timing Considerations
    – February elections were discussed but seen as challenging given fundraiser and endorsements.
    – March was identified as a realistic option if February is not feasible.
    – Next step: set a firm election date and communicate nomination process to membership.

    ## 11. Adjournment
    Ayo adjourned the meeting at 8:45 PM.

    —

    ## Action Items Summary
    1. Ayo to send outreach/follow-up lists for sponsorship targets and assign follow-up outreach (electeds, candidates, judges, honorees).
    2. Marquis to update the CODA website ASAP to prominently feature fundraiser details, QR code, and ActBlue dues link.
    3. Ayo + team to print a list of members/attendees who have paid (for check-in).
    4. Ayo to send honorary outreach letters and coordinate photo collection; Jenna to support certificate design.
    5. Ayo/board to send at least two member notices: dues, fundraiser, endorsements.
    6. Board to set and announce an election date and nomination process (aiming for February if feasible; otherwise March).
    7. Event team to determine restaurant tip amount at end of event and record it properly.CODA GENERAL MEETING MINUTES

Date: January 14, 2026
Time: 6:30 PM – approximately 9:00 PM
Location: 535 E 5th Street, NYC (with Zoom participation)

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

CODA held a full General Meeting focused on fundraising, committee structure, coalition work, and planning for the 2026 endorsement cycle. Key outcomes included:

  • Scheduling a Founders Fundraiser for Sunday, February 8, 2026 (tentatively 1–4 PM).

  • Activating multiple standing committees (Advocacy, Bylaws, New Members).

  • Receiving a coalition report on immigrant defense and small-business preparedness.

  • Endorsing Anthony Feliciano for Democratic State Committee, pending dues verification.

  • Establishing a two-meeting endorsement process (Feb 10 via Zoom; Feb 11 in person).

  • Tabling endorsement in the AD-74 special election pending further consideration.

  • Receiving a Treasurer’s report confirming limited but stable funds.

1. CALL TO ORDER

The meeting was called to order at 6:30 PM by Ayo (Co-President, Chair).

2. ATTENDANCE

Attendance was recorded via in-person sign-in sheets and Zoom participation.

Officers / Elected Officials Present

  • Ayo — Co-President (Chair)

  • Alana — Co-President

  • Esther — Treasurer

  • Marquis — District Leader

  • Anthony Feliciano — State Committee

  • Harvey — City Council

  •  

Remote / Zoom Participation

Several members and guests participated remotely, including individuals listed above who marked “online” on the sign-in sheets and additional Zoom participants visible on screen.

Procedural note: Voting eligibility and quorum are determined by members in good standing (2025 dues paid) and were subject to post-meeting verification by the Treasurer.

3. INTRODUCTIONS

A round of introductions was conducted for members and guests, including candidates and elected officials present. It was clarified that while candidates were present, the meeting was not a candidate forum unless otherwise specified.

4. MEETING SCHEDULE & LOGISTICS

  • CODA General Meetings are held on the second Wednesday of each month at 6:30 PM, unless otherwise noticed.

  • The current meeting space is reserved for the remainder of the year.

5. FUNDRAISER: HONORING CODA FOUNDERS

Event Details

  • Date: Sunday, February 8, 2026

  • Time: Tentatively 1:00–4:00 PM

  • Location: Restaurant space adjacent to the former Populari, E 51st St between 3rd & 4th Ave (east side)

  • Purpose:

    • Honor CODA’s founding members

    • Raise funds prior to endorsement season

Planning Notes

  • Flyer to be finalized and distributed by Friday.

  • Founders list (~32 names) being verified by Donna, Ted, Lisa, and Michael F.

  • Event is ADA accessible via a portable ramp.

  • Venue cost waived; tipping staff required.

Sponsorship & Program

  • Judges and candidates to be invited as sponsors (suggested $500 sponsor level).

  • Founders to be recognized via framed certificates (not plaques).

  • Photo montage planned showing CODA’s early history and recent advocacy work.

Action Items

  • Members to submit historical and recent photos.

  • Volunteers to coordinate slideshow assembly and submission instructions.

  • Leadership to finalize event title and messaging.

6. COMMITTEES

Sign-up sheets were circulated for the following committees:

Advocacy Committee

  • Purpose: Research, policy development, and issue advocacy.

  • Chair needed to convene meetings and report to membership.

Bylaws Committee

  • Co-Chairs: Esther and Donna

  • Tasked with reviewing existing bylaws and proposing updates.

New Members Committee

  • Focus on onboarding and engagement.

7. COALITION REPORT: INDIVISIBLE LES / COMMUNITY CARE COALITION

Members reported on participation in immigrant-support efforts, including small-business preparedness for ICE activity.

  • Trainings conducted on best practices and rights awareness.

  • Materials currently available in English and Spanish.

  • Identified gap: Need for Chinese-language materials and Chinese-speaking volunteers.

  • Plans discussed to expand outreach into the East Village.

8. ELECTIONS & ENDORSEMENTS

8.1 Endorsement Philosophy

The membership discussed endorsement strategy and affirmed that:

  • Endorsements may range from “paper endorsements” to deeper support.

  • Resource constraints limit extensive spending or petitioning.

  • “No endorsement” is always a valid option in any race.

8.2 State Committee Endorsement

A motion was made and approved to endorse Anthony Feliciano for Democratic State Committee, pending verification of quorum and dues status.

8.3 AD-74 Special Election

Discussion was held regarding endorsing Keith Powers in the AD-74 special election.
Concerns were raised regarding:

  • Process consistency,

  • Precedent,

  • Avoiding person-first endorsement decisions.

Decision: The matter was tabled for further consideration.

8.4 Endorsement Process & Scheduling

The membership agreed endorsements could not be handled in a single meeting and approved a two-meeting structure:

Tuesday, February 10, 2026 — 6:30 PM (Zoom)

  • NY-12 Congressional District

  • Attorney General

  • Comptroller

  • Assembly District 66

  • Assembly District 65 (incumbent)

Wednesday, February 11, 2026 — In-Person General Meeting

  • NY-10 Congressional District

  • Governor

  • Assembly District 74

  • Judicial candidates

  • Additional races as needed

Members were encouraged to review candidate materials and attend forums in advance.

9. TREASURER’S REPORT

Esther (Treasurer) reported:

  • Funds on hand: approximately $1,000 + $400 + $119

  • ActBlue is active and encouraged for contributions.

  • Annual dues are $25; several members paid dues at or around the meeting.

10. GOVERNANCE & INTERNAL ELECTIONS

  • Bylaws review is underway.

  • Discussion held regarding timing of internal CODA elections.

  • No final election date was set; Executive Committee to determine timeline. No current members 

11. MEMBER ENGAGEMENT IDEAS

Ideas discussed included:

  • Trivia nights

  • Karaoke

  • Bowling

  • Monthly restaurant meetups

A volunteer offered to explore possible venues.

12. ADJOURNMENT

The meeting was adjourned at approximately 9:00 PM.

 

  • CODA General Meeting –  Minutes 12/09/2025

    • Date/Time: Tuesday, Dec 9, 2025 – 6:30 pm

    • Key Guests:

       

      • Council Member Harvey Epstein (newly elected to City Council)

      • Congressman Dan Goldman (NY-10)

      • Jenna Meeham – LES Community Care Coalition / Hands Off NYC

      • Marquis Jenkins – District Leader, explaining County Committee

      • CoDA co-presidents/moderators: Ayo Harrington, Marquis Jenkins, with support from John Blasco

       

     

 

 

 

 

1. LES Community Care Coalition / “Hands Off NYC” – Jenna

 

 

  • LES Community Care Coalition formed during the Trump administration to counter harmful federal policies and protect immigrants and vulnerable neighbors.

  • Coalition brings together ~30 members: elected officials’ offices, faith leaders, community orgs, and residents.

  • Mission: respond to the rise in hateful and harmful federal policies, keep ICE out of community spaces, and make sure people know their rights (advocacy, rapid response, education).

 

  • Past actions

  • Policy workshop at St. Mark’s Church for small businesses, churches, orgs on how to set policies and plans if ICE shows up. ~100 attendees.

  • Upstander/bystander intervention training with NYC Commission on Human Rights at Middle Church.

    • Deportation defense training.

    • First Hands Off NYC Day of Action at Union Square; city-wide actions, “Know Your Rights” zines distributed.

     

  • Upcoming action:

     

    • “Coffee & Community” – Sat, 10am–12pm at ABC Beer Co. (Ave B)

       

      • Folding “Know Your Rights” zines and assembling whistle kits for future actions.

      • Materials meant to be shared with tenant associations, neighbors, PTA, gardens, etc.

        

  • Members encouraged to:

     

    • Visit Hands Off New York website for city-wide calendar and trainings.

    • Attend this weekend’s community action and future Hands Off NYC events.

     

 

 

 

 

2. Council Member Harvey Epstein – Priorities & Updates

 

 

  • Thanked CoDA for support and turnout at his community swearing-in, where he was sworn in by AG Letitia James.

  • Legislative priorities before year-end:

     

    • Street safety / “daylighting” and a package of traffic and “treat-bender” bills he hopes to pass by year end.

    • Airbnb bills: pushing back against efforts to weaken NYC’s short-term rental laws.

    • Housing reform & affordable housing:

       

      • Wants more family-sized units (2–3 BR) and senior housing, not just studios.

      • Pushing broader affordable-housing reform package into 2026.

       

    • Robert Brooks prison-transparency package (named for man murdered in prison): bill package delivered to the Governor with minor amendments; advocates optimistic for signing.

    • Medical Aid in Dying bill – also urging Governor to sign.

     

  • ICE raids & immigrant protection:

     

    • Highlighted recent ICE raids, including a Middle Church member seized; reiterated need to stand up against ICE practices, support community defense, and connect with Jenna & the coalition.

     

  • Political & organizing notes:

     

    • December 11th is last day Legislature sends bills to the Governor; many bills (incl. medical aid in dying, Shield bill protecting trans people) still pending.

    • Encouraged County Committee members to attend tomorrow’s County Committee meeting to select the Democratic nominee for his former Assembly seat.

     

  • Constituent services & engagement:

     

    • Assembly office staff (e.g., Joanna) still available for casework as the transition to the Council office continues.

    • Will be planning community events and visioning sessions early next year; wants CoDA’s help as a neighborhood partner.

    • Light moment: Harvey is now officially in Ayo’s East 4th Street block association—barred by bylaws from being block-association president but expected to show up at meetings.

     

 

 

 

 

3. County Committee 101 – Marquis Jenkins

 

 

  • Explained role of County Committee:

     

    • Elected Democratic Party members who perform key party functions.

    • One major role: selecting Democratic nominee in a special election when a seat becomes vacant.

     

  • For this vacancy:

     

    • 217 County Committee members in Assembly District 74.

    • Only those members within AD-74 can vote on Dec 10 to choose the Democratic nominee for Harvey’s former Assembly seat.

    • Special election expected late Jan or early Feb; nominee chosen by County Committee, but voters decide ultimate winner.

     

  • Encouraged County Committee members to attend and vote; non-members welcome to observe to understand the process.

 

 

 

 

4. 2026 Statewide Elections & Candidate Forums – Ayo

 

 

  • 2026 Democratic primaries for statewide offices:

     

    • Governor & Lt. Governor (now run as a single ticket chosen by the gubernatorial candidate, not separate primaries).

    • New York State Comptroller.

    • New York State Attorney General.

     

  • CoDA co-planning a large downtown candidate forum with 10–12 Democratic clubs, plus several college Dem chapters and Manhattan Young Democrats.

     

    • Save the date: Jan 29, 2026 – NY State Candidate Forum (location TBA; aiming for ~300-seat venue with overflow).

    • CoDA members will be invited to submit questions in advance; a question committee will curate and assign questions.

    • Forum will be followed by CoDA endorsement meetings, door-knocking, and canvassing from late Feb through the June primary.

     

  • Congressional races:

     

    • CoDA has EDs in NY-10 (Goldman) and NY-12 (currently Nadler, who is not running again).

    • CoDA will host or co-host forums for both NY-10 and NY-12; many candidates are emerging in NY-12.

     

  • Structural note: law changed so Lt. Gov no longer runs separately—they run as the Governor’s chosen running mate.

 

 

 

 

5. Congressman Dan Goldman – Federal Updates & Q&A

 

 

Immigration & ICE dragnet (main focus):

 

  • Described current ICE “immigration dragnet” in NYC, particularly at 26 Federal Plaza:

     

    • People with lawful asylum claims are being arrested at court appearances and ICE check-ins.

    • Many are now afraid to appear, with court watchers estimating ~75–80% no-show rate, forcing people underground and forfeiting legal claims.

     

  • Goldman’s district office across from 26 Fed has been converted into a support/triage center:

     

    • Welcomes families of detained people and anyone impacted.

    • Staff help with privacy waivers, track cases, retrieve property, connect people to shelter, health care, food pantries, etc.

    • Provides workspace for advocates and attorneys to file habeas petitions and supplement case records.

    • Coordinates closely with court-watchers and immigrant-rights groups.

     

  • Legislative response:

     

    • Introduced bill with Reps. Espaillat and Velázquez to prohibit ICE arrests of people attending court or ICE check-ins.

    • Working to maintain a visible congressional presence in immigration court; ICE behavior changes when members are physically present.

     

 

 

Government funding & shutdown risk:

 

  • Current short-term funding expires Jan 30.

  • Goldman believes odds of another shutdown are low—no one benefitted from the last one, and Republicans are also wary—but dysfunction makes nothing certain.

 

 

Medicaid, SNAP, and Dept. of Education cuts:

 

  • Medicaid cuts (from earlier Republican reconciliation bill) are already law but take effect at the end of next year.

  • SNAP cuts and new administrative burdens begin in January, increasing food insecurity.

  • Federal Dept. of Education is being hollowed out:

     

    • ~half of staff laid off; functions pushed to other agencies.

    • DOE’s core role is civil-rights enforcement, Title I, low-income and special-needs funding—so cuts will hit those students hardest.

     

  • Democrats are using oversight, letters, and public pressure to highlight these changes, but lack subpoena power in a Republican-controlled House.

 

 

Israel/Palestine & civilian harm:

 

  • Reaffirmed support for two-state solution and civilian protection.

  • Critical of Netanyahu and current Israeli government, says criticism of government policy is appropriate and necessary.

  • Supports ceasefire as an opportunity to:

     

    • Rebuild Gaza with international funding and create conditions for Palestinian self-determination and governance without Hamas.

     

  • Distinction he draws:

     

    • Criticizing Israeli government policy ≠ anti-Semitism.

    • Targeting or blaming Jews in the U.S. or Jewish students for Israeli government actions crosses into anti-Semitism.

     

 

 

Housing, NYCHA, and affordability:

 

  • Co-leads Public Housing Emergency Response Act with Rep. Velázquez – >$30B for NYCHA capital repairs (unlikely to pass soon).

  • Strategy is multi-pronged:

     

    • Oversight of HUD and NYCHA.

    • Expand tools like Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC); recent “big ugly” bill doubled bond capacity for affordable housing.

    • Use federal incentives to pair private developers with strict affordability requirements and enforcement.

     

  • Acknowledged massive housing shortage nationwide; rents rising in red rural areas has opened some bipartisan space on housing issues.

  • Supports the Green New Deal for Public Housing, while acknowledging timeline and political limits.

 

 

Wealth inequality & “Robin Hood Act”:

 

  • Introduced the Robin Hood Act:

     

    • Targets ultra-rich individuals who avoid taxes by taking loans against their stock holdings instead of selling.

    • Would tax those loans, raising ~$30B/year.

    • Revenue would fund universal childcare, universal pre-K for four-year-olds, and restoration of the expanded Child Tax Credit that cut child poverty ~50%.

     

 

 

Other quick-fire responses:

 

  • Hidden neighborhood gem: East 4th Street area (arts district) – quintessential New York.

  • Alternate career if not in Congress: Golfer.

  • Historical figure he’d bring to Congress for a day: Justice Thurgood Marshall (his idol; referred to as “Jack Gberg” / Thurgood).

  • Best advice he follows: Don’t lock yourself in; keep an open mind to opportunities and don’t be afraid to pursue them.

 

 

 

 

6. Local Initiatives & Community Service Announcements

 

 

  • Food distribution (next Wed, Dec 17):

     

    • St. Mark’s Church: large early-morning distribution, 7–10 am, needs volunteers (heavy lifting/unloading).

    • Sixth Street Community Center: food distribution 10 am–1 pm; will have a range of volunteer roles, including lighter-duty and seated jobs (intake, moving smaller loads, etc.).

    • Sean (now on Sixth Street Community Center board) to send written details; CoDA will circulate.

     

  • School-based pantries (District 1):

     

    • Superintendent Chan & Trinity Church partnership: dry-goods pantries in every D1 school.

    • Families with children in D1 schools can access food via school staff/security; more details to be sent and shared with CoDA members.

     

  • Coat/toy drives:

     

    • Toys currently a focus for Harvey’s office; Trinity Church (9th & B) always accepts coat donations.

    • Sixth Street Community Center has also been collecting coats.

     

  • Internships:

     

    • Harvey Epstein seeking interns (mentioned in his newsletter).

    • Dan Goldman’s office: internship applications open (must be 18+), for DC or NYC offices, deadline Dec 15; link to be shared by staff.

     

 

 

 

 

7. Internal CoDA Discussion & Next Steps

 

 

  • Member Albert raised concern that CoDA has focused heavily on elections and endorsements and wants more structured work on local issue campaigns.

     

    • Ayo noted CoDA’s recent local work (health-care advocacy, food giveaways, immigrant support, coat and food drives, etc.) but agreed that more issue-based programming should come via committees and Exec Board planning.

    • Plan to circulate a calendar of committee meetings, especially for the advocacy committee, and invite broader membership participation to set local issue priorities.

     

  • New/returning faces introduced themselves (e.g., CoDA co-founder Annie Wilson, John Trecco, Joseph “Puma” P., etc.). Members encouraged to email leadership with interests and to join committees.

 

 

 

 

8. Upcoming Dates & Reminders

 

 

  • Dec 10, 2025 – AD-74 County Committee Meeting

     

    • Vote for Democratic nominee for the special election to fill Harvey’s former Assembly seat. CoDA members urged to attend; only CC members vote.

     

  • Dec 12–14 – Hands Off NYC Community Weekend of Action

     

    • Includes ABC Beer Co. event (Sat 10–12) hosted by LES Community Care Coalition.

     

  • Next CoDA General Meeting:

     

    • CoDA usually meets 2nd Wednesday of each month; members asked to hold those dates through 2026 (notified if any are canceled or moved).

     

  • Jan 29, 2026 – Statewide Candidate Forum (Governor/LG, Comptroller, AG)

  • Future date TBD – NY-10 & NY-12 Congressional forums (CoDA will coordinate with other club

CODA General Meeting –  Minutes 11/12/2025 – 

Presiding Officers

  • Ayo Harrington – Co-President
    • Alana Sivin – Co-President
  • Donna Ellaby – Vice-President (online)
    • Esther Yang – Treasurer
    • Alberto Mercado – Secretary

Attendance

Members and Guests in Attendance (partial list):
• Ted Reich
• Carolyn English
• Rachel De Aragon
• Joseph Puma
• Anna Pycior (in person)
• Camille Napoleon – President of Baruch Houses (online)
• Eric Diaz – Vision Urbana (online)
• Assemblymember Grace Lee

John Blasco

Jesus Salas

Keith Powers

Kevin Okeefe

  • Monica from Assemblymember (soon-to-be Council Member) Harvey Epstein’s office
    •

Executive Summary

This meeting included major updates on SNAP disruptions, ICE enforcement escalations, health-care subsidy risks, food insecurity, environmental issues, and local safety conditions. Representatives from Congressman Dan Goldman’s office, Assemblymember Grace Lee, and Assemblymember Harvey Epstein’s office provided deep dives into ongoing crises. Candidates for the AD74 special election attended and shared their background in the community.  CODA also discussed community service programs, holiday food events, and upcoming political forums. Expanded federal, state, and local briefings are provided in the detailed sections below.

1. Welcome & Opening

Ayo Harrington and Alana Sivin opened the meeting by reaffirming CODA’s dual mission: building political power while remaining rooted in community-based service. They thanked Middle Collegiate Church for hosting and acknowledged the church’s multi-century legacy of social justice leadership.

2. Presentation – Middle Collegiate Church

A representative from Middle Collegiate Church( joe Puma) described its 400-year history, its leadership in LGBTQ+ advocacy, arts and culture programming, and racial justice. Members were invited to tour the newly rebuilt space following the devastating 2020 fire.

3. Federal Update – John Blasco (Office of Rep. Dan Goldman)

John provided updates on three intersecting federal crises affecting New Yorkers: SNAP instability caused by shutdown orders, escalating ICE detentions at 26 Federal Plaza, and Congressional threats to ACA premium subsidies. Expanded analysis is provided in Section 8.

4. State Update – Assemblymember Grace Lee (Expanded)

Assemblymember Grace Lee delivered a detailed update focusing on food insecurity, safety conditions, environmental health, and state-level emergency responses:

  • **SNAP Emergency Response** – Grace reported that hundreds of families have contacted her office about delayed or partial SNAP benefits during the shutdown. Many parents reported skipping meals for their children. She explained that the State stepped in to release November SNAP benefits despite the federal freeze. Her office coordinates with OTDA and local food-distribution partners like Vision Urbana.
  • **Universal School Meals** – Grace highlighted the statewide implementation of universal meals, calling it the most effective anti-hunger tool available during the SNAP crisis.
  • **Vision Urbana Holiday Program** – She emphasized the urgent need for bilingual (Mandarin, Cantonese, Spanish) volunteers and noted unprecedented demand for turkeys and pantry goods.
  • **Environmental Concerns** – Grace raised concerns about the Governor’s reversal on a natural gas pipeline project and expressed support for PFAS contamination protections.
  • **Sara D. Roosevelt Park Crisis** – She described rising disorder, drug-related debris, illegal vending, and insufficient sanitation. Her office is pushing for a multi-agency task force that includes Parks, DSNY, NYPD, and outreach teams.

5. State Update – Monica from Assemblymember/Elect Councilmember Harvey Epstein’s Office (Expanded)

Monica provided a broad update summarizing constituent services, immigrant-rights efforts, food programs, and the transition to the City Council:

  • **Harvey’s Transition to City Council** – Swearing-in scheduled for December 7. The Assembly office will continue full services during the transition.
  • **Know Your Rights Canvassing** – Monica described escalating ICE enforcement at 26 Federal Plaza and the need for court monitoring, legal coordination, and distribution of multilingual Know-Your-Rights resources.
  • **Holiday Food Initiatives** – The office is coordinating turkey drives, vegan roast distributions, and pop-up pantry events. Demand is significantly higher this year, especially after 4 PM when working families arrive.
  • **Bellevue Flu Clinic** – Part of a broader effort to increase vaccinations among seniors and NYCHA residents.
  • **Undercover Thanksgiving Dinner** – Coordinated with CoDA and local partners, serving over 200 residents with emphasis on dignity, privacy, and hospitality.

6. Assembly District 74 Vacancy – Candidate Participation

  • **Sarah Batchu** – Emphasized mutual aid, immigrant advocacy, and her CODA involvement.
    • **Kevin O’Keefe** – Highlighted nonprofit leadership, tenant support, and community organizing.
    • **Jesús Salas** – Discussed food-access programs, latino advocacy, and longstanding ties to community
    • **Council Member Keith Powers** – Discussed city council  legislation supporting artist housing and legalizing bodega cats.

7. Upcoming Events & Background

  • **Nov 15 – Hands Off New York** (Union Square, 2–3:30 PM)
    • **Nov 18 – AD74 Candidates Forum** (East Midtown Plaza)
    • **Nov 27 – CoDA Thanksgiving Dinner** (Volunteers needed)
    • **Ongoing – Food Access Resources** shared by Assemblymember Epstein’s office

8. Federal Crisis Briefing – SNAP, ICE Enforcement, ACA Subsidies

SNAP Breakdown During Shutdown

SNAP benefits were blocked from release despite prior allocation. Families received late or partial benefits, and many feared potential clawbacks. With only two national vendors processing benefits for all states simultaneously, a massive backlog formed during the shutdown.

Goldman Office Mitigation Efforts – SNAP

  • Coordinating with OTDA/USDA on benefit verification
    • Supporting food pantries like Vision Urbana
    • Publishing clear guidance on benefit rights
    • Partnering with state lawmakers on emergency relief

Escalation of ICE Detentions at 26 Federal Plaza

ICE and non-ICE reassigned federal personnel attempted to detain families outside immigration hearings, sometimes confiscating Know-Your-Rights materials. Confusion and rights violations increased during the shutdown.

Goldman Office Mitigation Efforts – ICE

  • Court-watcher alert system
    • Staff intervention on-site preventing detentions
    • ICE Privacy Waiver forms for tracking detained individuals
    • Coordination with DOE and shelters for minors
    • Congressional-letterhead flyers that cannot be confiscated

ACA Subsidy Risks

The continuing resolution contains provisions undermining ACA premium subsidies. New Yorkers may face higher premiums and loss of tax-credit protections.

Goldman Office Mitigation Efforts – ACA

  • Public opposition to subsidy cuts
    • Coordination with healthcare advocates
    • Alerts to clinics and FQHCs
    • Drafting alternative protections
    • Constituent navigation support preparation

9. Closing & Action Items

Members were encouraged to submit candidate-forum questions, volunteer for food-access events, support Thanksgiving efforts, join block-association outreach, and pay dues. The meeting adjourned with appreciation for all speakers and community partners.

 CoDA General Metting 9/9/2024
AGENDA:
1. Report back of CoDA events since the last meeting

a. Harris/Walz Work: DNC Watch Party, tabling for Vote Blue, CoDA Phone Bank
b. Outreach Committee Work: Project 2025

2. Vote on adoption of minutes from last meeting
3. Membership Welcome
4. Bylaws Change
5. Events coming up – Phone bank (open slots), debate party tomorrow
6. Other Business

1. Events Update

a. Phone Bank, DNC watch party, tabling

i. Phone Bank – First phone bank was a success, very easy to do

ii. DNC Watch Party – In collaboration with other clubs, packed at Mary O’s. Noted there was a protest for Gaza outside, which is important to acknowledge

iii. Tabling to promote Vote Blue buses, NY ERA Vote yes on Prop 1 and our phone banks and watch parties. There was good turnout, and it’s nice that this
is a Presidential because we don’t have to talk to locally registered voters.

b. Outreach Committee

i. Looking to do tabling throughout the community and focusing further east to engage local voters and promote club membership
ii. Using the Center for American Progress’ Project 2025 Impact on New York and including environmental impacts
iii. Looking to get voter registration information so people can register there
iv. Looking for more volunteers to table on these days with Donna
v. Working on a history of CoDA document w/ Michael Farrin

2. Bylaws Change

a. Style note: changed CODA to CoDA

b. Article 3, subsection 6 “Qualifications,” subsection A change to add language enabling staff members for elected officials to join the Executive Board. Limited to only the secretary position, included conflicts of interest and recusal policies. Read by Jacob Golden.

i. Ayo moves to vote, Donna objects
ii. GENERAL DISCUSSION:

1. Points in support: we don’t have a lot of people participating and that ifwe limit who can be members of the board, we may diminish
participation and membership. Our current policy is exclusive, and weshould change it to be inclusive. We don’t have to vote for people forthe Board who we don’t think will be good, so the board voting processshould be sufficient to address concerns over conflicts of interest.

2. Points in opposition: it will put the staffers on the board and the electedofficials in an awkward position if the club decides to support something
in opposition to the elected official. We don’t want to have electedofficials influencing the actions of the club, we want the influence to be
the other way.

                                 3. There is discussion that this amendment is currently put forth so Katie can join the Executive Board as co-secretary, however, everyone                                                   acknowledges that we have to be intentional and consider these changes irrespective of what they think of Katie or her work with CoDA or any                                           particular elected official. Everyone praises Katie, and genuinely believes she is amazing.

                                 4. Other points: What are other clubs doing, specifically other progressive clubs in the reform movement? If someone wants to participate and is                                       motivated, do they technically need the title to still participate?

                                 5. Members expressed wanting to add more nuance to the rule and try to make it work by addressing the conflicts of interest. A friendly                                                       amendment to add a sunset clause was denied. They said they would prefer to do more research, and called the question.iii. VOTE: 7 in favor, 4                                         opposed, 3 abstentions. Motion fails. Bylaw amendment is not adopted.

                                                          c. Additional bylaws changes should be discussed one item at a time, and this is the only item being discussed tonight.

3. Upcoming Events

a. Phone Banks every Wednesday with rotating hosts. Katie Loeb will send out the already decided on dates and Marquis Jenkins signed up to host.
b. Debate watch party at Donnybrook at 35 Clinton Street on 9/10. DNC is promoting the  event, and 65 people have signed up! Not anticipating overcrowding and there will beno sign up requirement to attend.
c. Vote Blue buses to swing districts are every Saturday. Harvey Epstein will be hosting a bus to Pennsylvania on 10/5.

4. Other Business

a. Marquis is spearheading a campaign against ballot measures 2-6. These came from a Mayoral charter revision and are overreaches of Mayoral powers, especially in regard to public safety and criminal justice.

i. Marquis is spearheading the field organizing and provided dates and times people can participate.
ii. CoDA can host outreach sessions below 14 th Street, but we have to make sure we have people to work it.
iii. More information regarding getting involved and breaking down the ballot measures are forthcoming.

           b. The work of the bylaws committee will continue to try to find nuance to the question of melected staffers being on the Executive Board, and other items.                      Emails for Michael Farrin will be confirmed because there was miscommunication related to the changes discussed tonight.

Move to adjourn: Alana, Second Esther

CoDA General Meeting 7/30/2024 AGENDA

A. District Leader Update on Judicial Elections 
B. Endorse on State Supreme Court Judge
C. Elect Executive Board. Current nominations include: 

 President: Alana Sivin 
 Co Vice Presidents: Ciara Lugo and Donna Ellaby 
 Treasurer: Jake Wolff 
 Corresponding Secretary: Katie Loeb 
 Recording Secretary: Albert Mercado 

D. Vote to endorse in the presidential election and plan for next steps, including weekly phone banks.
E. Update on state committeewoman 
F. Mount Sinai Beth Israel Update 
G. Announcements: Event in Support of Ana Irma Rivera Lassén on August 15 at 6PM, other
announcements 

A District Leader Update on Judicial Elections

 The Governor created three new judicial seats, we believe they will be serving in Family Court.
 The District Leaders had to last minute vote to fill these seats (brief discussion on process flaws)
 The judges who were selected are:

o Harold Bahr, a previous CoDA endorsee
o Liz Seamus, a strong disability candidate
o Crystal Villasenor, who was not voted for by our District Leaders but ran and dropped out of the judge race previously

 Ayo mentioned that this candidate had been previously registered as a
Republican, which caused many people to have concerns over her judgeship
 Ayo mentioned that all the Lower East Side representatives of color said they
believed she was too conservative, yet the white people selected her over their
concerns
 Alana mentioned that uptown leaders of color, including Melissa Mark Viverito,were advocating for Crystal, but the District Leaders of CoDA went with another candidate because of the concerns raised by Ayo and others in the community

 Judge preferred by our District Leaders but did not win

o Eric Worsthorn

B. Endorse on State Supreme Court Judge Discussion on Process

 People are elected judicial delegates to select who will appear on the Democratic line in the
General Election for all vacancies for State Supreme Court.

 Judicial Delegates for CoDA are: Donna Ellaby, Michael Schweinsburg, Michael Faran
 Judicial Delegate alternates are: Marquis Jenkins, Aura Olavarria
 Alana says supreme Court Judges are very important because they will often serve on weekends,
so they will determine bail for those arrested on weekends. They also determine if people are
issued orders of protection, help pro se clients, and other very important issues.
 Michael Faran says this process may seem opaque and like back room politics, but it is important
for protecting the integrity of a progressive judiciary because it makes sure people are vetted
and have support, and not someone who can buy their way into an election.
 Some clubs bind their Delegates to a club vote, but CoDA does not have this rule. Generally
there is an advisory poll and the delegates will have a first choice, but judges often count votes
and then drop out if they can’t win, so there’s some flexibility in judicial delegates.
Candidates and Discussion
 Donna Ellaby is supporting Jerrold Leibowitz because of his tenure in Housing Court. He was the only person who created a guide for tenants facing eviction, called a Tenants Rights Booklet so that all tenants knew their rights. This has subsequently been adopted writ large by the courts and is now the standard for tenants. He is being forced into retirement, so if we support him for Supreme Court he gets 4 extra years to serve on the court. We also get a Civil Court opening that we can select someone for.
o Q: KL – Does Supreme Court deal with housing issues?
o A: DE – They are assigned to other courts, so they can be assigned to Housing Court as
well as criminal, family, pro se/pro bono, etc
o A: AH – Supreme Court can hear anything except for cases against the state
 Alana Sivin spoke on a new organization that uses metrics to analyze how judges set bail, and
said that Jerry Liebowitz sets the highest bail, so she does not feel comfortable with voting for
him for judge. She prefers Judy Kim who was determined to set the lowest bail and prefers
Alternatives to Incarceration and other programs.

o Q: What other metrics do they look at?
o A: AS – They also look at what cases were overturned. We can look up how many of his
decisions are overturned. In Judge Liebowitz’s defense, they also track how transparent
judges are and how many decisions they write, and he has written a lot of decisions and
is rate transparent.
o MF – Overturned decisions are not really a great metric, so we should look into this with
a grain of salt.

 Ayo emphasized the importance of selecting people of color for these seats and would like more
information about the racial demographics of the court.
 AH – what is the process for the delegates to select judges? Does it reflect the CoDA
membership, or do the delegates make decisions on their own?

o AS: Some clubs bind their delegates with a vote, but CoDA does not have this in our
bylaws.
o MF: We have always said the delegates are not individual actors, but they reflect the
membership. In the past, we had the judges appear before the whole group, and then
took a poll of membership. This was just an advisory opinion, where you had a first
choice. The way it works is that people start counting up the vote and if they know they won’t win will drop out, so you can’t select your first choice. There is then some discretion on who to choose.

 Tito Delgado followed up Ayo’s point on race. He said that incarceration rates for Black and
Latinos are the highest, and if this particular judge is not rated very well, it is hard to push for
that. Our community has to be represented in this vote. There is a scale that they use, and this
particular judge did not do very well with leniency or parole and being a little fairer. I would go with Alana’s take on this because she is in the system and she has been in this system for quite a while now. She knows the players. We talk a lot of procedure issues, those are important, but wants to raise the issue of race that Ayo said. Too many people are going to jail and it’s a bad situation.
 Donna Ellaby said over the past 30 years she has been a judicial delegate, CoDA has supported
diversity as a significant issue and as a result the bench is much more diverse than it was in the
past. On the issue about the carceral decisions, I want us to move forward on the rest of the
agenda. I would like to contact the candidate and tell him this is an issue for our club and allow
him to provide a response to this. She will share this information with the club.
 Ayo asked if we could also have more information about Judy Kim. She also says that 85% of people in jail are from 11 neighborhoods that are majority Black and brown, including the Lower East Side.
 Edwin Hernandez asked where they stand on the Campaign to Close Rikers

o A: Harvey Epstein says that judges can’t take positions on these sort of campaigns
because they may hear related cases and would have to recuse themselves.
o A: AS – we can’t close Rikers if there are too many people in pre-trial detention, and
Judy Kim has shown that she is going to do this by sentencing fewer people to pre-trial
detention.

 Harvey Epstein says that white people are overrepresented in the judiciary. He shared statistics
on the representation based on population demographics, and says that Asian judges are
underrepresented.
 Ayo recommends there be a change in the bylaws to make the Judicial Delegates be binding.
 Harvey says we should add an agenda item to the next meeting to create a bylaws committee to
see if we can change our bylaws.
 Michael says that in the past it helps for us to call County and let them know what our decision
is in advance.
 Donna says she has spoken to 30 judicial delegates outside of community and she thinks there is
overwhelming support for Jerrold Liebowitz.
 Tito says that doesn’t mean that we should pick him.
 Katie moves to take an advisory poll of the club, Ayo seconds, acknowledging that this is just
advisory
 Discussion over whether to move forward with the advisory poll
 Jacob Golden asks that we have the poll be online due 48 hours before the vote.
 The poll will be sent out on Friday with the report on judicial ratings by Alana and information
from Donna

C. Executive Board Elections

Nominated Candidates
 President: Alana Sivin 
 Co Vice Presidents: Ciara Lugo and Donna Ellaby 
 Treasurer: Jake Wolff 
 Corresponding Secretary: Katie Loeb 
 Recording Secretary: Albert Mercado 
Discussion on the appropriateness of an elected official staffer to be on the executive.
 Next month when we discuss the bylaws, we will also include recusal policies for staff of elected officials staff if they are on the executive board for review.
 People expressed concern over elected official staff having influence over the process
 Others said that they don’t think this is a conflict of interest, and that it should be allowed for anyone qualified to join the board
 Decided no exceptions should be allowed, but that we would review the bylaws to enable Katie
Loeb to join the Executive Board in next meeting
Nominations from the floor
 Tito Delgado nominates Ayo Harrington for co-president, Alana Sivin seconds, Ayo Harrington

Accepts
 Esther Yang nominates herself for co-treasurer of the Board following Agenda Item D. The vote was reopened, and she was unanimously approved Election

 Slate unanimously approved
CoDA Board as voted: Co-Presidents: Alana Sivin and Ayo Harrington; Co-Vice Presidents: Ciara Lugo and
Donna Ellaby; Co-Treasurers: Jake Wolff and Esther Yang; Recording Secretary: Alberto Mercado
D. Presidential Election Endorse
Vote to endorse Kamala Harris in the Presidential Election

 Unanimously approved
Harvey Epstein requests sponsorship for buses to Pennsylvania and other States for $500 and a Kamala watch party on August 22 for $100
 Discussion on whether or not CoDA can donate money to the Vote Blue PAC
 Treasurer Jake Wolff is concerned that since CoDA is not a registered Political Committee, they are not able to donate to the Vote Blue PAC, which is how we endorse the buses
 Harvey said that we can give under $1,000 to a Federal PAC, which is what Vote Blue is
 Jake says that State law prohibits CoDA from making donations to political campaigns or
committees because CoDA is not a registered committee
 Ayo requests that executive board register us as a political committee

Vote to endorse bus and watch party, without donating any money (discussion continues without vote)
Ayo Harrington encourages everyone to donate money to the Kamala Harris campaign as well as sign up to phone bank. She is excited as hell that his woman is running. She is so happy. Rachel recommends to reach out to local community based organizations to see what they can do to get more people to vote. There are a lot of people in this community who do not vote, and we have to think of those organizations who can reach these people to get them to vote. We should think about how we can reach them and teach them.
 While nonprofits may not be able to endorse candidates, they can register people to vote, so we should get voter registration forms to these organizations.
 A member shared she is a community nurse and works with seniors with limited mobility and
some are homebound. She urges us to move with absentee ballots and get seniors to vote
absentee as they may not be able to leave their homes. She also wants us to focus on young
voters as well.
Project 2025 Discussion
 Center for American Progress has a one-page breakdown of this, which is pretty terrible for
basically everyone.
 Donna says that we should take this and add voter registration information to the bottom, and
take time to do outreach to high schools and around the community Further discussion
 Rachel requests to go to swing congressional districts in NY, the buses are going there
 Ted – this nomination of Harris is a wonderful thing for the Democratic Party and the country,
but we have to find a way… but CoDA has taken certain positions on Israel, BDS, and Gaza over
the year, and we have to find a way to participate with others to find a way to make sure that
she takes a more progressive position on solving the issues in the Middle East.
 Mark Hannay spoke on swing districts in New York State

E. State Committee Update

 State Comitteewoman Winfield was unable to stay to this time, but she did leave a report for
members to read (scanned and included)
F. Mt. Sinai Update from Mark Hannay
 The State Department of Health gave a conditional approval for Beth Israel to close
 The conditions:

o A 24/7 urgent care is conditioned to operate for 3 months, believe this is window
dressing to appease the community, and we must make sure people use it
o Mt Sinai will be required to give Bellevue money

 Next steps:

o There is a court hearing next Thursday, August 8 at 3:00pm, but this may no longer be
on the judge’s calendar, there is confusion over this. If this is happening, we will want to
pack the court room

G. Announcements
The Executive Board Members are hosting a fundraiser for Ana Irma Rivera

 Q: Tito If she doesn’t have a vote what is the point?
 A: Alana she still has influence and the current person is basically a Republican and doesn’t
represent us
 Q: Ted who is this person? I don’t remember this.
 A: Alana we voted on this last meeting and discussed the importance of supporting her due to the cultural history of the neighborhood. Alana also spoke on the progressive and significant
Legislation passed by Ana Irma.
 A: Tito she is also the head of the Puerto Rican Bar Association as well
 Q: Alberto historically the people on Puerto Rico have voted to remain a colony. If the people
there are continuing to vote to be a colony, what chance does she have?
 A: Ayo it’s not a colony, (discussion over this statement begins)
 A: Donna let’s not get too sidetracked on this and agree it’s important to educate people on this
issue.
 A: Tito to speak to your point it matters because she can be a voice and she can shake things up
 A: There’s something to be said for furthering autonomy and furthering self rule and control
over finances and infrastructure, and that in terms of decolonization is very important. And how it’s presented on the ballot is different from what people want. There will be a get out the vote with the downtown clubs. The date is being confirmed still, but aimingfor mid-September once people are back in school. VID is doing get out the vote at the target.
Donna suggests creating a committee on get out the vote. There follows discussion about whether we
should host a forum or town hall on this. Harvey Epstein is hosting one.
Mark said that Beth Israel is open and operating and it is providing excellent care. The nurse to patient ratio is among the best ratio in the city right now. So you get great nursing care there.
Other people are already doing a lot of work on Project 2025, so we should work with those groups on this Agenda Items for next month and follow up

 Send out Supreme Court Judge advisory poll on Friday
 Bylaws Committee for binding Judicial Delegates and elected official staff serving as an officer on the Executive Board
 Further discussion on registering as a political committee
 Form a committee on get out the vote and Project 2025 outreach and education

November 5th, 2023

CODA Yearly Retreat

Attendance

Adriana Gordillo, Albert Mercado, Jake Wolff, Alana Sivin

Moderator: Andrea Gordillo started 

 Agenda

 10am – Energizer, Icebreaker, and Welcome

  • Facilitator Pablo benson gave us a flavor for how the day will procede – what to expect
  • All in attendance stated their name – approximately how long with – CODA
  • Facilitor Pablo benson – introduced himself & gave us a small BIO

 10:20am – Group Agreements, Managing Expectations For The Day

  • Pablo explained – we will all break up into groups  – towards the end
  • Pablo explained – what is expected of us – in order to get the most of this exercise

 10:30am To 11:30am – Timeline Exercise, And Storytelling

  •  no queremos queso – queremos apartamentos
  • Diversity & strength
  • The majority is electoral
  • Struggle to become more issue oriented
  • “green groceries” – most successful issue campaign – 1998-2001
  • Vieques campaign – 2000
  • Issue based campaign – gain visibility
  • David & goliath fights
  • CODA people involved in other campaigns
  • Many movements of housing organizing
  • Are we democrats – or are we 2 club
  • Attracting people for our endorsement(s)
  • Electoral heavy – but also intentional list of block associations
  • Opposed to the democratic machine
  • Synergy between – electoral & political
  • Critical movement(s) – Guiliani era – 
    • watching multiple community fronts
    • UHAB
    • Gardens
  • A lot of targets in the – 90’s
  • DID film lecture series – community events and political education
  • Don’t blame CODA – stepping back from grassroots – electoral has it’s timeline
  • Democratic changes – asisan community- growing gentrification
  • Nexus between – old/new – local/global
  • Having 2 clear opponents – creates motivation(s)
  • Follow thru with electives
  • Opposition has becom – other persons organization
  • Overcome grudges
  • Tension between reform & transformation
  • Inside/outside strategy
  • Connecting movement(s) – to electoral committee(s)
  • Organizing around issues – bring in new people
  • Having an enemy focal point – can deter from objectives
  • Response & resilience – work was dropped
  • Healthcare potential campaign
  • Position to other progressive groups
  • Mutual aid – rapid response – as for of recruitment
  • Getting passed neighborhood beefs – difference on specific policy solution(s)
  • Political organizing has changed onlie causing tools – bigger tent
  • Build the organization – before others attack
  • Personality issues corroding coalition building
  • Joining in synergy

 Guiding questions to consider: 

  • What are some of our wins?
  • When did we stumble?
  • Who was here and isn’t here any longer?
  • When was there a breakdown?
  • Who have been our targets? 
  • What tactics have been effective?

11:30 – 11:40am – Stretch Break

11:40am – 1:15 – Who Are We – Spectrum Of Allies Activity.

Issue Campaigns’ Success: Discussion on various campaigns, including successful
issue campaigns like ” green groceries” and the Vieques campaign. Campaigns like
“green groceries” and the Vieques campaign demonstrated the effectiveness of issue-
oriented approaches. They highlighted how focusing on specific, tangible problems
within the community can garner support and visibility, contributing to the coalition's
credibility and relevance.


● Historical Context and Learning: Exploring past campaigns, such as during the
Giuliani era, provides valuable lessons and insights. Understanding the successes,
challenges, and strategies employed during these times informs the coalition’s current
approach and decision-making processes.


● Community Engagement and Grassroots Movements: Highlighting the involvement
in housing organizing, block associations, and grassroots initiatives demonstrates the
coalition’s commitment to engaging with the community at a local level. This involvement
strengthens trust and connections within the neighborhood.


● Adapting to Changing Dynamics: Recognizing shifts in community demographics, like
growing gentrification or changes in political landscapes, enables the coalition to adapt
its strategies. Adapting to these changes ensures that the coalition remains relevant and
responsive to evolving community needs.


● Building Alliances and Addressing Differences: Acknowledging tensions between
reform and transformation and addressing personality issues impacting coalition building
is vital. Building alliances, overcoming differences, and fostering unity are key to
maintaining the coalition’s strength and influence.


● Strategic Focus and Recruitment: Identifying target focal points, understanding the
significance of issue-based organizing for recruitment, and exploring new campaign
potentials, like healthcare initiatives, helps the coalition stay aligned with its progressive
objectives while attracting new supporters.

1:15PM – 2PM – LUNCH

2pm – 2:45pm – LES Power Map 

2:45 – 3:15pm – Energizer Activity

3:15 – 4:15 – Objective Setting

4:30pm – 5:30pm – Work Planning 

 

Dot Voting

 

Save Beth Israel 8

Ceasefire Now 7

Democratize the Democratic Party 6

Rad Pact Education 4

Comunity Land Trust 4

Quality of Life w Human Rights 2

Move The Money 2

Single Payer Healthcare 2

Invest in Our New York 1

Housing 1

Taxing Institution (NYU, Columbia) 1

Extreme Heat Bill

Just Cause Bill

Ceasefire Now

  • Feeder Marches
    • Mobilize when they are organized
  • Mobilize Other Clubs
    • Ask them to endorse resolutions
  • Contact NY Delegation
    • Letter, Conversations
  • Interfaith groups
    • Research and Sign on
  • Senior Center
    • One-on-One, Group Leaders, Make Calls
  • Political Education Events
    • Originate and Amplify Other Events
  • Silent Vigils
    • Join Events
  • Send Email Invitation
    • Paul Send Emalils

Ended 

 Recording Secretary

Albert Mercado – aka – ALM

October 12, 2023 – 7:00 PM
CODA General Membership Meeting
GOLES @ – 171 Ave B
(Minutes)

(Page 1)
Exe. Bd. Attendance Meeting Started 7:13pm
Andrea Gordillo, Jake Wolff, Albert Mercado
Local Politicians: ASM Harvey Espstein/Channel Eliot & John Blasco/ Dan Goldman’s Office,
Susan Mckeown, Nelson Valentine

Gen. Attendance : Allison Greenfield, Paul Bartlett, Rachael de Aragon, Ted Reich, Carolyn English, Mark
Hannay, Michael Quinn, Michael Schweinsburg, Valentina Jones, Edward Brunicardi

Virtual Attendance:
Laura Olenick

Moderator: Andrea Gordillo
ASM Harvey Epstein
 Briefly Discussed Situation In Israel
 Summary De-Briefed Us – County Committee Meeting
 Manhattan Must Do Our Part In Order Support Entire County Committee(S) – Get Stuff Done!!
 Mentioned May Be More Difficult Next Year To Get Stuff Done
 Mentioned Several Meeting(S) & Legislation(S) & Congressional Seats
 Mentioned For All Of Us To Get Involved With – NY Eye & Ear & Beth Israel – Being Closed
 Mentioned Building A New Coalition To Combat – Closing Issue(S) – NY Eye & Ear & Beth Israel
 Mentioned CC Could Support Clubs Like – CODA To Translate – Different Languages – For Transparency
John Blasco
 Dan Goldman Office Inundated With Questions – Crisis In Israel
 Briefly discussed about the – Legislated Process – How the City Council works
 The Speaker is elected by Council Members – Leads us in setting priorities and passing laws
 The Speaker also – Directs Public Money – For the benefit of all – New Yorkers
 The Committee Votes on any particular – Bill
 If the Bill passes the Committee by a majority vote – Then the Bill is sent to the Full Council
 Where it will be considered and voted on a Stated Meeting
 The Bill must again pass by a majority vote
 Despite numerous Bills on the floor – In the end the Speaker decides and pushes any Bill…
 Which is in the best interest – Of any given Speaker in charge

Vote Change CODA Bylaws
 Create Disability Rights Officer – The Disability Rights Officer Shall Be Responsible For Ensuring…
 All Policies, Procedures, Programs, Events, Etc – Are Viewed First Through A Disability Lens…
 Campaigns, Operations and Activities – The Officer May Also Hold an Executive Position…
 In The Absence Of An Officer – A Committee May Be Informed
 Members Should Fill Different Officer(S) – Within CODA
 Vote To Create – Disability Rights Officer – To Review Thru Disability Committee – Tabled For Now

Ongoing Campaign Updates
 Not Discussed

Event Planning – For Our Retreat & Upcoming Events
 SAVE THE DATE: November 5 th – 10am to 5pm – CODA Retreat – Location TBD!!
 Join our Executive Committee, members, and friends as we gather for a strategic retreat, plan our
campaigns, and break bread together…
 We’ll discuss the upcoming major elections, power mapping our neighborhood, local organizing, and
how to focus and improve our messaging. Light breakfast and Lunch will be provided to attendees…
 This retreat will be facilitated by Pablo Benson Silva. Pablo Benson Silva is currently Organizing Director
for the Citizen Victory Movement (Movimiento Victoria Ciudadana), an emergent progressive political
party in Puerto Rico. Born and raised in Puerto Rico, Pablo has just returned to his native country after
living in New York for 15 years…
 During his decade and a half in NYC he led and ventured into many projects around social movements,
participatory politics and solidarity economy. From organizing the largest municipality conference in the
United States with Fearless Cities North America in 2018 to co-directing the New York network of
workers&; cooperatives (NYC NOWC) for more than four years. His interest in enhancing the current
historical situation to achieve political and social change has led him to advise municipality campaigns
and grassroots organizations around the world…

Meeting Ended 9:07

Recording Secretary
Albert Mercado – aka – ALM

  Sept. 7th, 2023 – 7:00 PM
CODA General Membership Meeting
In Person – Loisaida Center at 710 E. 9 th . St / CODA zoom link

Executive. Board. Attendance                                                                                                                                          Meeting Started 7:13pm
Andrea Gordillo, Alana Sivin, Jake Wolf, Albert Mercado, Jesus Salas

Local Politicians
ASM Harvey Epstein, John Blasco/Cong. Dan Goldman Rep, Simone Kanter/Con. Dan Goldman Com. Dir,

Gen. Attendance
Christopher D. Grief/MTA ACTA Assesibility, Dave Brauswell, Alejandro Ep. , Michael Farin, Allison Greenfield, Paul Garrin, Joseph Puma, Michael Quinn, Lanette Murphy,

Virtual Attendance
Channel Elliot/Harvey Epstein Rep, Ted Reich
Moderator: Andrea Gordillo

CNM Harvey Epstein Reported

 Eleven (11) legislative victories in 2023 – New progressive agenda for 2024 legislation period
 East River update – Walk through with DDC (dep’t design & construction)
 Expediting working papers for Asylum Seekers
 Asylum Seekers being housed in NYCHA apartments that are being renovated by NYCHA
 Had a political mixer Sept. 5 th – 35 people attended
 Hang With Harvey – Summer Social W/Community – Political Mixer – Sept. 21 st – At 225 E. 27 th Street
 New Migrant Center – At 29 th Street
 NY Eye & Ear – Merging with BIMC – Numerous local politicians have voiced their immediate concerns

Congressman Daniel Goldman – Rep. John Blasco & Simone

 John also reported – East River update – Walk through with DDC (dep’t design & construction)
 John letter to MTA CEO/Chair – Janno Lieber – Delancey/Essex ADA Train Station – See Attached
 Signed by – Sen. Brian Kavanah, Cong. Dan Goldman, ASM Harvey Epstein, MPB Mark Levine…
 CMN. Chris Marte, CWM. Carlina Rivera – See letter attached

Christopher Grief – MTA ACTA – Advisory Committee On Accessibility

 Essex/Delancey ADA Train Station – Scheduled 2020-2024 Capital Expend.Project – See Attached
 Imperative Entire CB 3 Community – “Letter of Support with Signed Petitions”
 Submit Support Letter(s) & Petition(s) – MTA Government Affairs – 2 Broadway NY,NY 10004
 Christopher – All MTA’s Capital Projects – Are 1.5yrs Behind – Because COVID

   See Essex St/JMZ Trains & Delancey St/F Train

 

Updates Judicial Convention & County Committee

 The Count Committee consists of two members from each voting district in each municipality. The
members are elected at the June primary election
 On Thursday, August 10 th , the recently-elected Democratic Judicial Delegates of the 1 st Judicial District…
Convened for the Manhattan Democratic Party’s 2023Supreme Court Judicial Convention
 The following candidates were selected as the 2023 Democratic Nominees for the 1 st . Judicial District
 Hon. Phaedra Perry & Hon. Lyle Frank & Hon. Leslie Stroth
 The Democratic Party is governed by committees of the registered Democrats, from the National
Committee level, down to State Committees, and then local community levels
 Joe Biden – President
 National Democratic Committee
 Democratic State Committees – District Leaders & State Committee Members
 Democratic County Committee – District Leaders & County Committee Members

SALT Meeting – Delancey Street Subway Accessibility Campaign

 CODA has partnered with like-minded groups such as GSD/Grand St. Dem’s & Other Democratic Clubs
 SALT/Senior Advocacy Leadership Team & Cong. Daniel Goldman
 Deputy Chief of Staff – For Con. Daniel Goldman – John Blasco – Created thread which included
 Seven Local Politicians – From Districts 1+2 – All of which signed a letter addressed to (attached)
 MTA Chair & Chief Exec. Officer – Janno Lieber – Regarding Accessibility – Essex/Delancey Train Station
 ALM shared info at meeting Tuesday 8.29/2pm with SALT Team – “Senior Leadership Team”….
 Bill Ferns from GSD was also present – GSD means – “Grand St. Democrats”
 Plan is to visit CMN Christopher Marte Office – Weeks of Sept. 11 th or 18 th – Revise Attack Plan
 ALM will invite – CWMN Carlina Rivera & ASSBLMN Harvey Epstein – Attend or Send Representative
 We also plan on meeting personally with – MTA CEO Janno Lieber – Discuss Updated Station Info, etc
 ALM & Bill Ferns & SALT will also “Attend & Talk” at MTA Board Meetings
 Keep MTA board Members – “Feet To The Fire”
 ALM suggested SALT to hold – Press Conference or Rally(s) – At Delancey/Essex Train Station
 ALM suggested contacting – District 1 & District 2 – Local Politicians & Political Clubs
 ALM will contact- “DIA & “CIDNY” – Regarding support with – 50-100 Wheelchairs at Rally(s)
 “DIA” means – “Disabled In Action” – “CINDY” means – “Center for Independence of The Disabled NY”

Voting Changes To CODA (bylaws)

 Voted to table until next meeting

Meeting Ended 8:17pm

Recording Secretary
Albert Mercado – aka – ALM